Excise Taxation Jobs 2026 Sindh – Narcotics Inspector & Assistant Narcotics Control Inspector Opportunities

Hello applicants! I am back with another amazing opportunity for those searching for government jobs in Sindh. If you are looking for Excise Taxation Jobs 2026 in Sindh, this is a golden chance you shouldn’t miss. This is an official government recruitment, advertised both in the Tribune newspaper and on the Sindh Job Portal (https://tribune.com.pk/epaper/2026-03-17/1?page=5), so you can verify it yourself.

This 2026 recruitment includes prestigious positions such as Narcotics Inspector (BPS-14) and Assistant Narcotics Control Inspector (BPS-11), with a total of 383 vacancies available across major districts, including Karachi, Sukkur, Hyderabad, Matiari, and Nawabshah. These positions are open to graduates who meet the required eligibility criteria and fulfill the physical fitness standards.

These roles are not just about employment—they offer an opportunity to actively contribute to law enforcement and community safety through the Sindh Narcotics Control Wing. The department has also reserved quotas for women, minorities, differently-abled individuals, and transgender candidates, ensuring a fair and inclusive recruitment process.

Applicants are required to pass the General Screening Test (STS) and meet the physical fitness requirements, ensuring that only qualified and capable candidates are selected.

Joining the Excise, Taxation & Narcotics Control Department provides not only career stability, structured government pay scales, and long-term growth, but also a chance to serve the province responsibly. In this article, we will cover all crucial points in detail, including eligibility, available positions, how to apply, physical test requirements, quotas, and other important information, so that you can apply confidently and accurately without any confusion.


Excise Jobs 2026 Vacancy Details (Narcotics Inspector & Assistant Narcotics Control Inspector)

Hey there applicants! This section provides a complete overview of the latest Excise Taxation Jobs 2026 in Sindh. To help you understand all the important details at a glance, we have included a table summarizing the key information about these high-demand government positions.

Job Details – Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh
Date Posted / Updated17 March, 2026
Category / SectorGovernment
Education RequiredBachelor’s Degree (minimum 2nd Division) or equivalent CGPA from HEC-recognized University
Area / TownKarachi & Other Areas
Vacancy LocationKarachi, Sindh, Pakistan
OrganizationExcise, Taxation & Narcotics Control Department
Job IndustrySecurity / Law Enforcement Jobs
Job TypeFull Time
Expected Last Date to Apply15 April, 2026 (or as per newspaper ad)

Key Highlights:

  • Positions Available: Narcotics Inspector (BPS-14) & Assistant Narcotics Control Inspector (BPS-11)
  • Total Vacancies: 383
  • Quotas Distribution:
    • Rural: 60%
    • Urban: 40%
    • Women: 15%
    • Differently-abled: 5%
    • Minority: 5%
    • Transgender: 0.5%
  • Eligibility: Bachelor’s degree from an HEC-recognized university
  • Physical Requirements: Male – Minimum height 5’5”, chest 33” with 1.5” expansion, 1-mile run in 8 minutes. Female – Minimum height 5’2”, 800 meters walk in 14 minutes
  • Application Portal: Sindh Job Portal (SJP)

These roles are ideal for candidates looking to build a secure government career while contributing to law enforcement and community safety in Sindh. Make sure to check all details carefully before applying, as eligibility, quotas, and deadlines are strictly enforced.


Eligibility Criteria for Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh

This section provides a complete and in-depth guide to the eligibility requirements for the Excise Taxation Jobs 2026 in Sindh. Before applying, it is crucial to understand that every government job has specific eligibility standards, and this position is no different. Only candidates who meet these requirements will successfully pass the initial screening.

The eligibility criteria for Narcotics Inspector (BPS-14) and Assistant Narcotics Control Inspector (BPS-11) are designed to ensure that applicants are qualified, capable, and ready for practical law enforcement duties. Physical standards, educational qualifications, and quota requirements are not just formalities—they ensure that selected candidates can perform the field responsibilities effectively.

If you do not meet the eligibility requirements, don’t worry. Visit JobExplain.com regularly, as we provide daily updates on the best government jobs in Sindh, explaining all details in depth. Your dream job could be featured tomorrow!

Eligibility Overview Table

CriteriaNarcotics Inspector (BPS-14)Assistant Narcotics Control Inspector (BPS-11)
Age Limit21–28 years21–28 years
Educational QualificationBachelor’s Degree or equivalent CGPA from an HEC-recognized universityGraduation or equivalent CGPA from an HEC-recognized university
QuotasRural 60%, Urban 40%, Women 15%, Differently-abled 5%, Minority 5%, Transgender 0.5%Rural 60%, Urban 40%, Women 15%, Differently-abled 5%, Minority 5%, Transgender 0.5%
Physical Standards (Male)Height 5’5”, chest 33” with 1.5” expansion, 1-mile run in 8 minutesHeight 5’5”, chest 33” with 1.5” expansion, 1-mile run in 8 minutes
Physical Standards (Female)Height 5’2”, 800 meters walk in 14 minutesHeight 5’2”, 800 meters walk in 14 minutes
DomicileProvince of SindhProvince of Sindh

Key Points to Understand

  1. Practical Relevance: The physical standards ensure that candidates are capable of performing law enforcement duties, which may include patrolling, inspections, and fieldwork under challenging conditions.
  2. Screening Warning: Candidates who do not meet these criteria will be rejected at the initial screening stage. Carefully compare yourself against the table above before submitting your application.
  3. Quota Compliance: Each quota is enforced to ensure fair representation, inclusivity, and adherence to government rules. Meeting quota-specific eligibility can improve your chances of selection.
  4. Official Source Verification: All eligibility criteria are taken directly from the official advertisement on Tribune E-paper and verified on the Sindh Job Portal (SJP).

How to Apply for Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh

If you are interested in the Excise Taxation Jobs 2026 in Sindh, a common question is: “How can I apply correctly without making mistakes?” This section will guide you step-by-step on the official application process and explain how to avoid common errors that often lead to rejection.

Important Guidelines Before Applying

  1. Official Method Only: Always apply through the official method mentioned in the government advertisement. For these jobs, applications must be submitted via the Sindh Job Portal (SJP).
  2. Avoid Common Mistakes:
    • Do not enter incorrect or inactive phone numbers, email addresses, or personal details.
    • Double-check spelling and formatting before moving to the next page.
    • Use recent, clear photographs and scanned original documents. Make sure files are properly named and in the correct format.
    • Never trust anyone asking for money to process your application. All official applications are free.
  3. Trust Official Sources: Verify information against the official newspaper advertisement (Tribune E-paper) or the Sindh Job Portal.

Step-by-Step Application Process

  1. Visit the Official Portal: Open the Sindh Job Portal (SJP).
  2. Create / Login Account: If you are a new user, register with your personal details. Existing users can log in with their credentials.
  3. Select Job Category: Navigate to the Excise Taxation & Narcotics Control Department Jobs 2026.
  4. Read Instructions Carefully: Go through the official instructions and eligibility criteria before starting your application.
  5. Fill in Application Form:
    • Enter accurate personal information
    • Choose your quota category (Rural, Urban, Women, Minority, Differently-abled, Transgender)
    • Check all spellings and formats
  6. Upload Documents:
    • Recent, clear passport-size photograph
    • Scanned academic certificates
    • Any other required documents
  7. Review Before Submission:
    • Double-check all fields, documents, and uploaded files.
    • Ensure no missing information or wrong entries.
  8. Submit Application: Once verified, submit your application officially.
  9. Print / Save Confirmation: After submission, download or print the confirmation slip for your records.

Key Tips to Avoid Rejection

  • Eligibility First: Only apply if you meet the eligibility criteria. Non-eligible candidates will be rejected during initial screening.
  • Correct Documents: Make sure all scanned documents are original, clear, and properly named.
  • Trust Official Sources: Use only Sindh Job Portal and official newspaper ads.
  • No Payments: Official applications are free—never pay anyone for your application.
  • Regular Updates: Keep visiting JobExplain.com for updates on deadlines and guidance.

By following these steps carefully, you can confidently apply for Excise Jobs Karachi 2026 or any other government jobs in Sindh without mistakes and increase your chances of selection.


Expected Salary & Benefits – Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh

Hey applicants! I know one big question in your mind is always: “How much will I earn in this job?” or “What benefits will I get?”. Let me explain this clearly.

Being a government job, the official advertisement does not disclose exact salaries. What is mentioned is the BPS (Basic Pay Scale). However, we can give you an estimated salary range based on research and similar government roles. This will help you get a realistic idea for motivation and planning.

⚠️ Note: These are expected salaries. The exact pay will be confirmed only after appointment and official posting.

Expected Salary Table

PositionBPS ScaleApproximate Salary (PKR)
Narcotics InspectorBPS-1450,000 – 60,000 (basic) ~ 65,000 – 70,000 with allowances
Assistant Narcotics Control InspectorBPS-1135,000 – 40,000 (basic) ~ 45,000 – 50,000 with allowances

Benefits & Perks

  1. Government Job Security
    • Posts are under Sindh Civil Servants Act 1973, ensuring long-term job stability.
  2. Allowances & Perks
    • House rent allowance
    • Medical allowance
    • Conveyance / travel allowance for field duties
  3. Career Growth Opportunities
    • Promotions based on BPS increments and performance
    • Training programs in law enforcement and narcotics control
  4. Other Benefits
    • Pension after retirement
    • Paid leaves and annual increments
    • Recognition and prestige as a law enforcement officer

Why This Section is Important

  • Even though the official ad does not mention salary, knowing expected earnings helps you plan and stay motivated.
  • This role combines respect, security, professional growth, and field experience, making it a valuable government job in Sindh.

Physical Test & Selection Process for Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh

For all applicants aiming for the Excise Taxation Jobs 2026 in Sindh, understanding the physical test and selection process is crucial. These standards are not merely formalities—they ensure that selected candidates are fully prepared for real-world law enforcement responsibilities.

General Screening Test (GST)

The first step in the selection process is clearing the General Screening Test (GST) conducted by Sukkur IBA Testing Services (STS).

  • Minimum passing marks: 40%
  • Test content: Multiple-choice questions covering general knowledge, English, and reasoning skills
  • Consistent practice with previous STS papers improves confidence and reduces careless mistakes, giving candidates a significant advantage.

Physical Test Requirements

Physical fitness is essential for duties in the Narcotics Control Wing, including field inspections, patrolling, and enforcement activities. The official requirements are:

RequirementNarcotics Inspector / Assistant Narcotics Control Inspector
Male HeightMinimum 5’5”
Male Chest33” with 1.5” expansion (34.5”)
Female HeightMinimum 5’2”
Run / WalkMale: 1-mile run in 8 minutes; Female: 800 meters walk in 14 minutes

Many candidates find the running and walking test challenging initially. Regular training, even simple daily jogging or brisk walks, significantly improves endurance. For instance, candidates who consistently practice short daily runs before the test often perform comfortably and pass without difficulty. This highlights how preparation and consistency make a real difference in achieving success.

Departmental Interview

Candidates who pass the physical test are then called for an interview by the Departmental Selection Committee.

  • Ensure all documents are original, properly scanned, clearly named, and in the correct format.
  • Present yourself professionally with confident body language.
  • Be ready to answer questions on eligibility, motivation, and your understanding of Excise & Narcotics duties.

To avoid common mistakes:

  • Provide accurate personal information—avoid typos, incorrect numbers, or inactive emails.
  • Trust only official sources: Sindh Job Portal and the official newspaper ad (Tribune E-paper).
  • Never pay anyone for application processing; all official submissions are free.

Final Selection

The final selection considers:

  1. GST performance
  2. Physical fitness standards
  3. Interview performance
  4. Compliance with eligibility criteria (education, age, domicile, quotas)

Success in this process depends on consistent preparation, authenticity, and adherence to official guidelines. Candidates who follow the steps carefully, train physically, and prepare mentally have a strong chance of joining the Excise & Narcotics department and serving Sindh effectively.


Contact Information & Official Sources for Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh

Alright applicants! If you’re serious about applying for the Excise Taxation Jobs 2026 in Sindh, the first thing you need to understand is that official sources and verified contact information are your safest and most reliable guides. There is a lot of misleading information online, and relying on unofficial sources can lead to rejection of your application.

Official Portal & Application Link

  • Always use the official Sindh Job Portal (SJP) for your application: https://sjp.gos.pk
  • This is the only platform where your eligibility will be verified, and official job announcements are published.

Newspaper Advertisement Reference

  • Check the original advertisement for reference: Tribune E-paper 17 March 2026
  • This ensures that the information you follow is 100% authentic and reliable.

Official Contact Helplines

  • For any queries or issues during the application, contact the Excise, Taxation & Narcotics Control Department using the official details provided on the SJP.
  • Avoid random phone numbers or social media contacts—these are often fake or unreliable.

Key Tips to Stay Safe & Avoid Mistakes

  1. Never pay anyone for processing your application; official applications are completely free.
  2. Double-check all links, deadlines, and instructions using the official portal or newspaper advertisement.
  3. Ensure all your documents are original, properly scanned, and correctly named before submission.
  4. Regularly visit JobExplain.com for updates, guidance, and detailed explanations on this and other government jobs in Sindh.

By following only official sources, verifying every step, and submitting correct information, you can confidently apply and maximize your chances of selection.


Deadline / Last Date to Apply for Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh

As you all know, every task or job has a specific timeline, and applying for government jobs is no different. If you miss the deadline, your application will automatically be rejected, no matter how perfect your documents or eligibility are.

For these Excise & Narcotics Control Jobs 2026, the official last date to apply is 15 April, 2026. Anyone trying to submit after this date will be disqualified.

Tips to Avoid Missing the Deadline

  1. Apply Early for Better Chances
    • I always suggest applicants submit their application as soon as possible. Early submissions are better in case of any portal issues or document problems.
  2. Start Preparing a Week Before
    • At least one week before the deadline, start filling out the online application, organize your documents, and scan certificates properly.
  3. Set Reminders & Notes
    • Use your phone or planner to set up reminders and alarms to make sure you don’t forget the last date.
    • Keep a checklist of required documents and eligibility criteria ready while applying.

Remember, timeliness is just as important as eligibility. Following the deadline strictly shows professionalism and ensures your application is accepted without any issues.


Interview Tips & Preparation Guide for Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh

Alright applicants! In this section, I’m going to give you practical guidance so that you can walk into your Excise & Narcotics job interview with confidence, fully prepared, and clear about what to expect. I’ll also share some common mistakes to avoid, because your interview performance plays a critical role in final selection.

Understanding the Full Selection Process

Before the interview, remember that there are multiple stages:

  1. Applying online via the official portal
  2. Initial screening & document verification
  3. Shortlisting candidates
  4. Written test (if applicable)
  5. Personal interview
  6. Final selection

The interview is a major stage and often determines your final chances. That’s why preparation and confidence are key.


Pre-Interview Preparation

  1. Know the Role Inside Out
    • If you’re applying for Narcotics Inspector or Assistant Narcotics Control Inspector, familiarize yourself with the duties and responsibilities of Excise & Narcotics Control.
    • Prepare answers for common role-based questions, such as:
      • “Why do you want to join Excise & Narcotics?”
      • “How will you handle field duties?”
      • “What do you know about narcotics control in Sindh?”
    • Think practically—your answers should show understanding of field duties, law enforcement responsibilities, and ethical behavior.
  2. Mock Interviews at Home
    • Practice speaking clearly and confidently.
    • Ask a family member or friend to simulate interview questions.
    • Today, AI tools can also help you practice mock interviews and receive feedback, which is a great way to prepare beyond just reading notes.
  3. Document Organization
    • Carry all original documents and properly organized photocopies.
    • Make sure certificates, degrees, and STS results are correctly named and clearly scanned.

During the Interview

  1. Timing & First Impressions
    • Arrive at least 10 minutes early—this shows professionalism and punctuality.
    • Dress neatly, sharp, and professional. First impressions matter, so look confident but not overconfident.
  2. Confidence & Honesty
    • Maintain eye contact while answering questions.
    • Speak clearly and honestly—exaggeration or false claims can hurt your credibility.
    • Be calm, polite, and show loyalty and integrity.
  3. Handling Questions
    • Prepare answers for common questions, but also be ready for follow-ups.
    • Examples of questions to prepare:
      • “Why do you want to join Excise & Narcotics?”
      • “How will you handle field inspections?”
      • “Explain your knowledge about narcotics control in Sindh.”
    • Ensure your responses are practical, confident, and concise.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Arriving late or unprepared
  • Carrying incomplete or disorganized documents
  • Relying on unofficial information
  • Showing overconfidence or nervousness
  • Ignoring the physical standards or role-specific knowledge

Practical Tip

Many successful candidates practice daily, prepare their documents, and rehearse answers, which builds both confidence and clarity. Being well-prepared often makes the difference between success and rejection, so take the preparation seriously.


Final Tips & Takeaways for Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh

Alright applicants! After covering eligibility, application process, interview preparation, and document organization, it’s time to summarize everything into quick, actionable tips that will make your journey smoother and increase your chances of success.

1️⃣ Follow Official Sources Only

  • Always apply via the Sindh Job Portal (SJP): https://sjp.gos.pk
  • Double-check all information with the official newspaper advertisement: Tribune E-paper 17 March 2026
  • Avoid social media tips or random contacts asking for money—all official applications are free.

2️⃣ Check Your Eligibility Carefully

  • Compare your age, education, and physical standards against the official advertisement before applying.
  • Only apply if you meet all eligibility requirements; failing the initial screening is a waste of time.
  • Keep the eligibility table handy while preparing your documents.

3️⃣ Organize Your Documents

  • Carry all originals and properly scanned copies.
  • Name your files correctly and make sure scans are clear.
  • Keep everything in the correct order for quick verification during the interview.

4️⃣ Prepare for the Interview

  • Arrive at least 10 minutes early.
  • Dress neatly and professionally; first impressions matter.
  • Be honest, confident, and focused. Maintain eye contact while answering questions.
  • Practice mock interviews at home using friends, family, or AI tools.
  • Prepare answers for common questions:
    • “Why do you want to join Excise & Narcotics?”
    • “How will you handle field duties?”
    • “What do you know about narcotics control in Sindh?”

5️⃣ Avoid Common Mistakes

  • Don’t arrive late or unprepared.
  • Avoid disorganized or missing documents.
  • Never rely on unofficial information.
  • Don’t exaggerate or lie in answers.

6️⃣ Build Confidence & Motivation

  • Practice regularly and review all steps before the interview.
  • Keep track of quotas, physical requirements, and STS results.
  • Stay calm, positive, and professional throughout the process.
  • Remember, being well-prepared often separates successful candidates from others.

7️⃣ Quick Action Checklist

  • ✅ Verify eligibility and quotas
  • ✅ Organize originals and scanned documents
  • ✅ Apply via official portal only
  • ✅ Practice common questions and mock interviews
  • ✅ Dress professionally and arrive early
  • ✅ Stay confident, honest, and focused

By following these final tips, you’ll have a clear roadmap from application to interview and be fully prepared for Excise Taxation Jobs 2026 Sindh. Stay committed, follow official sources, and trust your preparation—it will pay off.


Top 10 FAQs – Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh

1. What are the available positions in Excise, Taxation & Narcotics Control Department Sindh 2026?
The department has announced vacancies for Narcotics Inspector (BPS-14) and Assistant Narcotics Control Inspector (BPS-11). Both positions are open for applicants with a Sindh domicile and the required educational qualifications.
2. What is the last date to apply for Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh?
The official deadline for submission is 15 April 2026. Applicants are advised to apply early to avoid technical issues and ensure all documents are submitted correctly.
3. What are the eligibility criteria for Narcotics Inspector and Assistant Inspector?
Educational Qualification: Minimum Bachelor’s degree (2nd division or equivalent CGPA) from an HEC-recognized university.
Age Limit: 21–28 years.
Physical Standards: Minimum height and chest requirements for men; minimum height and walking standards for women.
Additional quotas: Rural 60%, Urban 40%, Women 15%, Differently-abled 5%, Minority 5%, Transgender 0.5%.
4. How can I apply for Excise Jobs 2026 in Sindh?
Applications must be submitted online via the official Sindh Job Portal: https://sjp.gos.pk. Applicants should ensure they have all required documents, recent photos, and STS certificates ready before applying.
5. Are there any common mistakes applicants should avoid?
Yes, some common mistakes include: Applying after the deadline, submitting incomplete or unclear documents, relying on unofficial information or social media tips, incorrect spelling, or wrong email/phone numbers.
6. What physical tests are required for Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh?
Male: Minimum height 5’5”, chest 33” (expandable 34.5”), 1-mile running in 8 minutes.
Female: Minimum height 5’2”, 800 meters walking in 14 minutes.
Physical fitness tests are mandatory, and failure to meet standards will disqualify candidates.
7. Is there a screening test before the interview?
Yes, applicants must pass the General Screening Test conducted by Sukkur IBA Testing Services (STS) with at least 40% marks. STS certification is required to proceed to the interview stage.
8. What documents should I bring for the interview?
Original educational certificates and degrees, STS certificate, domicile certificate, recent photographs, and copy of the online application. Ensure all documents are organized, scanned clearly, and properly named.
9. How can I prepare for the interview of Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh?
Practice common role-based questions like handling field duties, narcotics knowledge, and reasons for joining Excise & Narcotics Control. Conduct mock interviews at home. Dress professionally and arrive early to make a strong first impression. Be confident, honest, and maintain eye contact during the interview.
10. Where can I find official updates and notifications for Excise Jobs Sindh 2026?
Official Sindh Job Portal: https://sjp.gos.pk. Newspaper Advertisement: Tribune E-paper 17 March 2026. Always trust official sources and avoid paying anyone for job guidance.

Conclusion – Excise Jobs 2026 Sindh

Alright applicants! Throughout this article, I have explained every detail and depth of the Excise & Narcotics Control Jobs 2026 in Sindh. From eligibility criteria, application process, physical standards, interview preparation, expected salary, benefits, and common mistakes to avoid, everything has been covered carefully.

I hope by now you fully understand the requirements and are ready to apply confidently without missing anything important. Remember, avoiding common mistakes is just as important as fulfilling eligibility.

This is truly a great government job opportunity for all eligible candidates. So, make sure to apply before the deadline, prepare thoroughly, and use the official portals and sources only.

💡 Pro Tip: If you successfully land this job, share your experience and feedback in the comment section. Your insights will help future applicants and guide them to succeed.

Also, don’t forget to visit JobExplain.com daily for more government job updates, detailed explanations, and step-by-step guidance to stay ahead in your career.



Disclaimer: We are not affiliated with the Excise, Taxation & Narcotics Control Department, Government of Sindh or any other government body. All information regarding Excise & Narcotics Jobs 2026 is shared in good faith, based on the official advertisement and verified sources. Always confirm details directly via the official Sindh Job Portal: https://sjp.gos.pk and Tribune Newspaper Advertisement before applying. Beware of fraudulent recruiters and never pay for job applications.

Important Verification: All details in this article about Excise & Narcotics Control Department Jobs 2026, including available positions, eligibility requirements, application procedure, expected salaries, physical standards, and interview tips, have been carefully cross-checked with the official advertisement. Make sure to submit your application before the 15th April 2026 deadline to avoid missing this rewarding government opportunity. For official updates and confirmation, always refer to the Sindh Job Portal: https://sjp.gos.pk and Tribune Newspaper Advertisement.

Shani Imanatullah

Shani Imanatullah

Founder of JobExplain.com

I am a government job researcher and professional blogger with over 7–8 years of blogging experience. Since 2021, I have been publishing detailed and verified government job updates to help Pakistani applicants understand opportunities clearly and apply correctly.

Before publishing any job post, I carefully read the complete official advertisement, verify details from the relevant government website, and cross-check deadlines, eligibility criteria, and application procedures to ensure authenticity and accuracy.

Having personally applied for multiple government jobs, I understand the confusion and lack of guidance that many fresh graduates face. That experience motivated me to create JobExplain.com — a platform where job ads are not just posted, but properly explained in depth so applicants can fully understand every requirement.

I regularly update older posts whenever new official information is released, ensuring that readers always have access to current and reliable guidance.

📍 Serving Pakistani Job Seekers
💼 Government Jobs Researcher & Career Guide
🔎 My mission is to provide transparent, authentic, and structured guidance for every applicant.

All job information is sourced from official advertisements and relevant government portals. Applicants are advised to verify details from the official website before applying.

3 thoughts on “Excise Taxation Jobs 2026 Sindh – Narcotics Inspector & Assistant Narcotics Control Inspector Opportunities”

Leave a Comment